[Ask Inna] More Answers to Your Hashimoto’s Questions (Part 2) - Inna Topiler

Want my insights on what is REALLY going on with your thyroid?


[Ask Inna] More Answers to Your Hashimoto’s Questions (Part 2)

Your Hashimoto’s Questions and the Role of Your Metabolic Type

Last week I shared some of the questions you wanted answered about Hashimoto’s. I covered topics like the relationship between heavy metals and Hashimoto’s, the role the adrenals play in Hashimoto’s, the relationship between Epstein-Barr Virus (EBV) and Hashimoto’s and how to reduce the risk for kids of people with Hashimoto’s. All of them were very important questions that have a lot to do with the triggers of Hashimoto’s. If you missed it, here is a link to episode 068

In this episode, I answer more of your questions about Hashimoto’s. 

Question #1: With Hashimoto’s, is TSH a reliable indicator of the body’s thyroid hormone needs? If not, what else can we use to know what the body needs?

This can be very confusing for anyone with Hashimoto’s. The short answer is, no. TSH is not a reliable indicator. The ranges  for TSH are very broad (typically between about 4.5 – 5 depending on where you live. This range is not really optimal. The optimal range for TSH is between 1.8-3 (if you’re on thyroid medication this shifts a bit). 

But, TSH is only one indicator and you need to look at the big picture including your total T4, free T4, total T3, free T3, and reverse T3. This is because TSH is not actually created in the thyroid – it’s the thyroid stimulating hormone created in the pituitary gland. So, only looking at TSH doesn’t tell us which hormones the thyroid is producing and at which ratio. And, it doesn’t tell us how well the body (primarily the liver and the gut) are converting these hormones or how the hormones are actually utilized. Essentially, TSH shows a very very small part of a much bigger picture and that is why its not nearly complete. With Hashimoto’s you also want to track your antibody levels so that you can determine which triggers (listen to episode 068 for more on the four triggers) are affecting you and your levels. 

I’ve listed the various tests I recommend to get the whole picture of your thyroid functionality and optimal levels for each in the show notes for episode 027. If you are looking for a lab to do these tests, here is a link to a helpful resource and lab

I’m in the process of creating my thyroid course which is going to get way more in depth about this and how you can figure out your pattern and exactly what to do about it. The course will launch this fall. Add your name to the wait list if you’d like to be personally invited to join. 

Question #2: Why does someone with Hashimoto’s feel tired all day long? How can we help this and what can we do to wake up feeling refreshed and have more energy throughout the day?

While Hashimoto’s is an issue, we need to look at the root cause of the fatigue. It’s true that Hashimoto’s causes the immune system to attack the thyroid and often causes hypothyroidism which has a common symptom of fatigue. So, the first step is to make sure that you are supporting thyroid function optimally with what your body needs (foods, supplements or if necessary thyroid medication that is dosed appropriately) and you are also by avoiding Hashimoto triggers (noted in last week’s episode).

If you are doing these things and continue to feel tired, then you may want to consider the role your adrenal glands may be playing in your fatigue. The adrenals and the thyroid are very interrelated. Stress is a key trigger for Hashimoto’s and it can also impact adrenal function. 

Clean eating is also recommended but if you continue to feel tired, you may be having some issues with absorption which could be caused by a gut issue. This could be the real cause of the fatigue as well 

And finally, check that you are not deficient in nutrients that help us feel more energized like iron, B12 and other B vitamins.  As you can see, feeling tired is quite multi faceted so we have to look at it from all angles.

Question #3: My diagnosis of Hashimoto’s only came after being on thyroid medication for years. Can this medication be contributing to Hashimoto’s? 

In my opinion, I don’t think it did. What often happens is that the Hashimoto’s is undiagnosed for many years. Conventional doctors will often stop looking for answers once they diagnose hypothyroidism. So, the Hashimoto’s may have been there or been developing all along. I don’t think that the medication could cause Hashimoto’s because whether you’re taking a synthetic hormone or a natural, desiccated hormone, you’re just replacing the hormone that the body is failing to produce. One thing that could be setting off the immune system is a sensitivity to corn. Some medications are made with cornstarch so a small amount, everyday could be causing a reaction from the immune system so that is something to look into and perhaps change to a compounded medication with no fillers can help.

Question #4: Do you have to eat after taking Levothyroxine? And, can it be taken when doing a water-fast?

Levothyroxine or L-thyroxine is a T4 medication prescribed to some people with low thyroid function. It is meant to be taken on an empty stomach and you don’t need food later to help it absorb. So, in the case of a water-fast, it should not impact the effectiveness. However, water-fasts should be done under the guidance of a health practitioner so make sure they know you’re taking Levothyroxine. 

Question #5: How can you lose (or gain) weight when you have Hashimoto’s

I had multiple people ask me about this – both people looking to lose weight and people struggling to maintain or gain weight. 

We know that the thyroid has a big effect on metabolism. Once again, it’s important to look at the full hormone picture (not just TSH levels) to determine if the thyroid is not functioning optimally. If everything looks good, then the next place to look is at the food you’re eating – specifically any foods that you may have a sensitivity to. Food sensitivities can cause inflammation resulting in water weight gain. Hormonal imbalances may also be impacting the metabolism. 

The other big thing to consider is your metabolic type. We have different metabolic types, some people are protein or fat types and some are carb types. The protein types tend to do better with higher protein and fat whereas the carb types tend to do better with some carbs and less fat. If you are eating counter to your type (even if it’s super healthy) you may struggle to lose or gain weight. Also if you combine too much fat with too many carbs (even if they are good fats and good carbs) that tends to have a negative effect on our metabolism. While calories are not everything, how we combine our food does make a big difference. 

For anyone struggling to maintain their weight or gain weight the first thing to check is that you’re not over medicated or over-supplemented. Next, watch for triggers that may be causing Hashimoto’s flare ups. These can send your thyroid into hyper mode and then drop back down to hypo mode. And, like the weight loss issue, make sure you are eating for your metabolic type and for you, combining good carbs with good fats would in this case be a good thing. 

Question #6: Does the ketogenic diet help or hurt people with Hashimoto’s?

There’s a few opinions on this and it depends on how you look at it. While keto can be great for weight loss and blood sugar support as well as some neurological issues,  going on the Keto diet can be very stressful to the body – which is one of the main triggers of Hashimoto’s. It depends on your adrenal health and what your body can handle.

The second thing to consider are food sensitivities. Many people with Hashimoto’s can’t do dairy but dairy plays heavily in the Keto diet. If you are unsure if dairy is an issue, do a food sensitivity test before diving into the Keto diet. Finally, consider your metabolic type. If you are a carb type, then the Keto diet (Hashimoto’s or not) is not going to be a good choice for you. Even without a food sensitivity test – trust your body. If you don’t feel good doing the Keto diet – if you feel tired and hungry – then it’s not the right approach for you.

Question #7: Do people with Hashimoto’s need to stay away from iodine? If we’re using  pink salt and there’s no iodine, can we become deficient?

In general, too much iodine is contraindicated in Hashimoto’s.  I follow Dr. Kharrazian’s research. It shows that iodine can affect TPO (thyroid peroxidase) and create more issues with Hashimoto’s. I experimented with high-doses of iodine about 12 years ago and found that it really made me feel terrible and more susceptible to colds. So, from my experience, and the research, I don’t recommend it. Having said that, we do need a small amount of iodine because it does support the thyroid but also it’s really important for breast tissue. Small doses of iodine (about 250 micrograms) should be enough to prevent deficiency but it won’t set off Hashimoto’s. For most people, this level of iodine is going to be included in a daily multivitamin. Remember that iodized table salt is processed so it’s not the healthiest way to get your iodine. It’s better to use good quality sea salt and get the necessary iodine in your multivitamin. 

Eliminating Health Mysteries

Do you know someone struggling with autoimmunity or Hashimoto’s? Share this episode with them. It could help them regain their health and give them hope because the answers are out there!


Resources mentioned:

Lab Testing: https://yourlabwork.com/innatopiler/

Suggested Products

Complete Multi (with a small amount of iodine that is safe) B12 Iron

Related Podcast Episodes:

Navigating the Thyroid Treatment Mystery with Inna Topiler Solving the Thyroid Mystery w/ Inna Topiler Demystifying Food Sensitivities (and What You Can do About Them) Solving the Autoimmunity Mystery w/ Inna Topiler

Thanks for Listening

If you like what you heard, please rate and review this podcast. Every piece of feedback not only helps me create better shows, it helps more people find this important information.

Never miss an episode –  Subscribe NOW to Health Mysteries Solved with host, Inna Topiler on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and remember to rate and review the show!


All information, content, and material on this podcast is for informational purposes only and is not intended to serve as a substitute for the consultation, diagnosis, and/or medical treatment of a qualified physician or healthcare provider.

Some of the links provided are affiliate links. This means we may make a very small amount of money should you choose to buy after clicking on them. This will in no way affect the price of the product but it helps us a tiny bit in covering our expenses.

Site Design Rebecca Pollock
Development Alchemy + Aim